Real Estate

Rare ‘storybook home’ on private island in Connecticut on sale for $1.3M

Get your own private island, complete with a picture-perfect house, and still be able to catch a Metro-North train into the city.

The ultimate vacation home, near New Haven, Connecticut, has just gone on the market for a fraction of the cost of a Hamptons estate.

The home is on the Long Island sound but a short trip off the shore from Connecticut. waterareahomes.com
One of the bedrooms from the island home. waterareahomes.com
The island has a dock where a ferry stops and can drop you off near train service. waterareahomes.com

The 2,038 square-foot home sits on Belden Island, a 1-acre piece of land in the middle of Long Island Sound that is part of the Thimble Islands, off the coast of Branford, Conn.

The island has its own sandy beach and private dock and is serviced by a ferry that stops just a short ride from a nearby Amtrak and Metro-North train station.

One of four bedrooms. waterareahomes.com
The home’s kitchen. waterareahomes.com
Two fireplaces are located inside. waterareahomes.com
The island has its own private beach. waterareahomes.com

“The mainland town or village is called Stony Creek, and it is a charming fairy-tale location to begin with. Then you leave the shore and you head out into the Thimble Islands, and each one is different, but they all have a common history,” the listing agent, Margaret Muir, told Realtor.com.

The porch wraps around the entire home. waterareahomes.com
The cost of the house is slightly over $1 million. waterareahomes.com
The home has four bedrooms, two bathrooms and includes all the furnishings. waterareahomes.com
The island home is considered seasonal. waterareahomes.com

On the market for $1,295,000, the house has four bedrooms, two bathrooms and includes all the furnishings, as well as 2 acres of deeded shellfish beds, which have been rented out to people who harvest the oysters, Muir said.

“It’s a seasonal house as it is. At the end of the season, you would drain the pipes and close it up, and look forward to the next spring,” Muir said. “The house itself looks like it’s out of a storybook,” she adds. “It’s really very charming and sweet. You feel like you’re stepping back in time.”